Area 12: The U.S. During the Struggle for Civil Rights
Question: How successful was the U.S. in creating a more equitable society?
Lesson Plan Developed By
1. Students learn the history of Wind River Reservation water rights
2. Students learn about water-related lawsuits, whites vs. Indians, in Wyoming and Montana
3. Students learn about water law in Wyoming
Click here to see a spreadsheet aligning Wyoming State Social Studies and Common Core Standards for this and other digital toolkits of Wyoming History.
We will update the standards spreadsheet as more lesson plans are developed.
One 45-Minute class period
Resource 1: Summary
Resource 2: Article
"Native Rights to Wind River Water”
The exercise asks students, after reading the summary and the longer article, to read part of the 1868 treaty between the federal government and the Shoshone; and to list what the government promised to do for, and give to, Shoshones that wanted to farm. Based on the list, students will write an essay answering some questions about the content of the treaty sections.
Read the first two paragraphs of Article VI, and all of Article VIII, of the "Treaty With the Shoshonee and Bannacks. July 3, 1868.” List the things the government promised to do for, and give to, the Shoshones that wanted to farm. Using this information, write a 250-300 word essay answering the following questions: Did the government require the Shoshone people to farm their land? Were they making it easier or harder for the Shoshone to farm? Use the information from what you read to support your answers.
Study and discussion questions:
The 1868 treaty between the federal government and the Shoshone mentions water in only two passages, both identifying early natural boundaries of the reservation. There is no mention of water use or water rights. Why not, given the importance of these issues in Wyoming?
The Winters doctrine was a U.S. Supreme Court decision, but the Wyoming Supreme Court, which is a lower court, later modified it. These modifications weakened the water-rights protections granted to tribes by the Winters doctrine. Do you think the lower court was right? Why or why not?
Given that Indian reservations are sovereign nations, with autonomous governments, do you think it was legal for the Wyoming Supreme Court to impose state water-law requirements on the Shoshone and Arapaho for their water use on the Wind River Reservation? Why or why not?
Resource 1: Topic Summary
Virtually all of Wyoming is too dry for farming. Before many white people arrived, generations of native people lived here by hunting game and harvesting from wild native plants. By the mid to late 1800s, white settlers attempting to farm and ranch discovered that annual rainfall was rarely enough to support crops or feed for livestock. So they began to irrigate, drawing on nearby rivers and creeks. This was the beginning of water-rights disputes in Wyoming.
In 1868 the federal government and Shoshone tribe signed a treaty creating the Wind River Reservation, then called the Shoshone Reservation. (The Northern Arapaho tribe arrived 10 years later.) The government encouraged and sometimes pushed the Shoshone and other Western tribes living on reservations to farm or ranch. Therefore, they needed water, always scarce in the West. High demand generated many disputes, including a number of lawsuits in Wyoming, involving the Shoshone and also the Arapaho.
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1908 that treaty lands had water rights along with those lands, granted at the time the treaty was signed. According to this decision, known as the Winters doctrine, the Shoshone and Arapaho on the Wind River Reservation had water rights dated 1868—much earlier than, and therefore better than, the water rights of white settlers who came later. This was important in Wyoming, where territorial and then state water law gave priority to those holding the earliest water rights. Priority means the user could take water out of a river or stream first, ahead of all users with a later claim to that water.
Although Wyoming’s first two federal judges upheld the Winters doctrine, thus protecting the Reservation’s 1868 water rights, other lawsuits followed, including one authorized by the Wyoming legislature when the city of Riverton in 1975 announced plans to drill for groundwater. Shoshone and Arapaho leaders objected, citing the 1868 treaty giving them ownership of all the groundwater under their reservation lands. This complex lawsuit, involving more than 20,000 square miles and 20,000 water claimants, continued for 37 years, from 1977-2014.
After much litigation and some contradictory rulings, the tribes’ treaty water rights were upheld, though narrowed, and also made subject to state water laws. The tribal engineer’s office continues to work to implement Wind River water rights, but many questions remain about who will manage and fund these efforts, and about other water-related issues in the area.
Resource 2: Article
The article "Native Rights to Wind River Water” offers substantial background on the topic for teachers and for students 9th grade and up. The article may be demanding for younger readers.
For further reading
- “Treaty With the Shoshonee and Bannacks. July 3, 1868.” Jacksonholehistory.org, accessed Jan. 3, 2020 at http://jacksonholehistory.org/wp-content/uploads/1868-treaty.pdf.
- “Coming to Wind River: The Eastern Shoshone Treaties of 1863 and 1868.” May 23, 2018. WyoHistory.org, accessed Jan. 7, 2020 at https://www.wyohistory.org/encyclopedia/coming-wind-river-eastern-shoshone-treaties-1863-and-1868.
- MacKinnon, Anne. “Native Rights to Wind River Water.” Feb. 15, 2019. WyoHistory.org, accessed Dec. 23, 2019, at https://www.wyohistory.org/encyclopedia/native-rights-wind-river-water.
- The photo of the main stem of the Wind River is by Tom Rea.
For more background see these articles on Shoshone and Arapaho people and on the Wind River/Bighorn Basin on WyoHistory.org:
- The Arapaho Arrive: Two Nations on One Reservation
- The Tribes Sell Off More Land: The 1905 Agreement
- The Bighorn Basin: Wyoming's Bony Back Pocket
For many more Northern Arapaho and Eastern Shoshone learning objectives, lesson plans, videos and other resources, visit Wyoming PBS's Native American Studies page at https://wyoming.pbslearningmedia.org/collection/native-american-studies/.